Introduction to click fraud activity within PPC advertising and strategies for preventing it
PPC campaigns are a powerful tool for driving traffic and generating leads. However, hidden within this strategy is a high risk of click fraud. This fraudulent activity involves generating false clicks on PPC advertising manually or by bots to waste marketing budgets and skew performance data. Therefore, it is important to understand and combat click fraud.
In this guide, we’ll define click fraud within the context of cybersecurity, exploring its implications and the steps you can take to reduce the risks. We’ll review various strategies and tools designed to protect your PPC ads from fraudulent clicks. We’ll provide practical insights to help you protect your investments. Whether you’re an experienced marketer or a novice to PPC advertising, this guide will arm you with the knowledge needed to improve the performance of your advertising efforts and maximize ROI.
What Click Fraud is and Why it Matters
Photo by Jon Tyson on Unsplash
Click fraud refers to intentional clicking on online content, both as organic or paid advertising, with harmful or competitive motives. This typically affects display ads, sponsored search results, links shared on social media, or even across your own website. The goal is to exhaust an advertiser’s marketing budget, undermine ad performance or ad visibility, or even profit illegally from the cost of that click, which is ad fraud.
Click fraud related to organic content is the work of scammers seeking to gain a competitive advantage by overloading your site or sabotaging your efforts by introducing misleading data into your analytics. A whole industry focused on using programmatic ads and defrauding users has emerged. With the rise of paid-to-click apps and click farms, creating multiple fake clicks is becoming more simple. These tactics are also used to make illicit profits, with enterprising criminal organizations using new technology and malware to commit click fraud, potentially making millions of dollars.
What is Ad Fraud?
Ad fraud is a deliberate and systematic type of click fraud that is often used to fraudulently increase revenue for website publishers, mobile app developers, or content on social media posts and videos. While the terms ad fraud and click fraud are often interchangeable, there are clear distinctions between them. Click fraud may occur accidentally due to poor ad placement or indeed maliciously, for example when competitors try to exhaust your marketing budget. In contrast, ad fraud is always motivated by the intent to enrich the fraudster.
Is Click Fraud Really a Big Problem?
Actual fraud rates vary depending on:
- Business sector
- Geographic location
- Time of year
Nonetheless, different industries experience substantial fluctuation in fraudulent ad clicks. The sectors most affected by fraud include:
- Photography – 65%
- Pest Control – 62%
- Locksmith – 53%
- Plumbing – 46%
- Waste Removal – 44%
A few other important industries that experience high rates of click fraud include real estate (31%), financial (20%) and legal services (14%). Click fraud impacts every industry, including 90% of all Google Ads campaigns.
The Practice of Click Fraud
Photo by Bermix Studio on Unsplash
There are several reasons behind engaging in click fraud or ad fraud. This scam can take place across various digital marketing channels, including organic search, paid ads, social media platforms, in-app promotions.
The common reasons for receiving fake clicks on PPC ads are:
- Envious competitors or hostile customers who seek to damage your online presence or tarnish your brand reputation
- Fraudulent developers who’ve devised a method of generating income by clicking on your ads, using fake publisher inventory
- Malware apps or software designed to generate revenue from advertising, often using bots
- Paid-to-click apps that offer users monetary rewards for clicking or viewing ads in exchange for a small bonus
The Main Sources of Fake Clicks or Click Fraud
Multiple clicking on someone’s ad seems tedious. A competitor clicking on your ads several times a day may not have a strong impact on your ad budget, but there are more harmful ad clicking techniques to be aware of.
1. High-volume clicks
- Bots and web crawlers are created to navigate the web in search of information, or data collection. Some bots are friendly and simply gather contact information, while others may have malicious intent, clicking on your ads repeatedly to drain your advertising budget.
- Click farms are created to click on special links and are used by companies to artificially increase their subscriber or engagement levels. They are employed for liking social media profiles, viewing videos, sharing content, leaving comments, and repeatedly clicking on ads.
- Fraud networks and botnets are created as a combo of publisher websites and automated bots to defraud advertisers. A developed network of fraudulent bots with a complex infrastructure is designed to fraudulently generate income from video views from computers.
- Ad fraud often involves placing ads on sites that are unlikely to attract real traffic while offering site owners a chance to enhance their earnings. This multifaceted issue covers various elements, so you should explore our ad fraud prevention guide for more insights.
2. Medium to low volume clicks
- Competitors may try to drain your PPC budget by boosting their ad’s ranking for relevant searches. They may click on your ad each time they see it, which can be quite damaging to your campaign.
- Human error leads to invalid clicks. When people are searching for information, they may accidentally click on your site on SERP and then quickly leave without realizing that it is a paid advertisement.
- Vindictive persons, such as your former employee or dissatisfied customer, may have a motive to repeatedly click on your ad just to irritate you. It’s wise to consider reaching out with an apology.
Who is Affected by Click Fraud?
All businesses suffer from automated click fraud. Areas with great traffic and high-value keywords provide ample opportunities for fraudsters to operate undetected at a low risk of getting caught. Sectors such as law, dentistry, locksmithing, and water damage repair are often susceptible to high rates of click fraud, largely due to intense competition and high CPC. Companies using Google Ads or Bing Ads are also at risk of click fraud.
Dealing with Invalid Clicks in PPC Campaigns
Click fraud is a serious and growing problem and requires a number of measures to be taken to reduce the risk. Leading search engines such as Google and Bing have developed strategies to address this problem. For instance, Google actively blocks certain behaviors, such as high bounce rates, which often indicate accidental clicks or automated scrapers, and multiple visits from the same IP address. Nevertheless, you need to identify suspicious activity on your own and initiate a refund request.
Identifying multiple clicks from certain sources is not the hard part. The real challenge is the increasingly sophisticated methods of click fraud. With software that replicates human behavior, changes IP addresses via VPNs and proxies, and click farms that trick search engines, other tools are often needed to reduce the risk of click fraud. Using special click fraud prevention software is the most effective approach to address the issue.
How to Identify Click Fraud
There are several manual checks available to investigate potential fraudulent activity within your ad campaigns. While these methods may not provide a completely accurate picture, they can offer a helpful framework and might highlight some of the more evident violations.
1. Checking IP addresses
Use tracking tools such as WordPress plugins to log the IP addresses of your site visitors. Review your website visitor logs to determine how often the same IP address appears over a given period. If some IP address or unknown location is constantly visiting your site, it may serve as a warning signal, prompting you to consider blocking that IP address or location. Google provides some level of protection against repeated visits from a single IP or device. While it is not foolproof and may not fully meet your own criteria, it serves as a measure to minimize potential problems.
2. Checking publishers
Reviewing the list of publishers is necessary to monitor the effectiveness of your advertising. If you suspect that some sites may be engaging in fraudulent activities, you can block them from your publisher list. Common signs of scams include websites that are overloaded with advertisements, with little or no content, and recently registered domains.
3. Monitor campaign activity
Unusual interaction patterns or sudden spikes in activity may indicate that your ad has been targeted by malicious users. This is especially obvious if you notice a high number of clicks but minimal actual interaction. Also, a disproportionately high CTR from an area unrelated to your target market could be a red flag. For instance, if you run a company in the US and get a flood of clicks from other countries without any conversions or sales, this could indicate that you have fallen victim to a click fraud scheme.
Click Fraud Protection Strategies
Despite all of the above, detecting various forms of fraudulent traffic is challenging. Scams that mimic human behavior or use proxy servers are difficult to detect on your own. As they constantly evolve and grow more complex, keeping up with new trends in fraud can be daunting. This is where anti-click fraud strategies come into play, offering support in addressing these issues.
1. Remarketing campaigns
Remarketing is an effective campaign strategy, targeting individuals who have previously visited your website by displaying ads on partner sites. This approach helps keep your brand top-of-mind and may even foster repeat business. A key advantage of remarketing campaigns is that your ads are shown exclusively to those who have already expressed interest in your offerings. Additionally, it can reduce the risk of exposure to bots or click farms, particularly if your ads are tailored to specific geolocation.
2. Adjust your targeting
Adjusting your ad campaign targeting can strongly minimize your PPC campaign’s vulnerability to fraudulent activities. By excluding certain geographies, languages, demographics, and devices, you can significantly improve the performance of your advertising. If you notice suspicious activity from some demographic groups, consider excluding them and monitoring the impact. You can always revert this change if necessary.
Conclusion
The rise of click fraud poses a serious risk to ad budgets and the overall performance of PPC campaigns. Setting a strong click fraud prevention strategy is crucial to protecting your investment and ensuring your ad spends lead to real traffic and measurable outcomes. It’s important to recognize multiple types of click fraud that come from various sources, such as competitors intentionally clicking on your ads, bots designed to mimic user activity, or unethical practices from seemingly legitimate sources.
Having gained a clear understanding of these risks and using advanced click fraud detection tools, you can implement several preventive measures. Many platforms provide automated solutions that monitor click patterns and detect potential fraud in real-time, allowing you to receive immediate alerts and act quickly. Regularly improving your PPC campaigns can strengthen your defense. Adjusting your ad targeting settings can enhance ad delivery while reducing the risk of fraudulent clicks.
By staying informed and proactive, you can create a solid defense against click fraud, optimizing your PPC investments for greater ROI and further growth. Through a blend of vigilance, technology, and strategic planning, you can effectively navigate the click fraud challenges and protect your advertising budget from unnecessary losses. By making use of these tips, you can secure your spends while improving the performance of your PPC ads.
